Tiffanie Debartolo

Monday, January 18, 2021

REVIEW: Sorrow by Tiffanie DeBartolo


OUR REVIEW:


To be honest, trying to write a review for Sorrow seems like such an injustice to the experience of reading it. But it would be an even bigger injustice if I didn't let the world know that I read it and loved it. The people who happen across this blog or review have to know that this is a MUST READ. 

Ever since Tiffanie DeBartolo posted the first hint, the first suggestion, that she was writing this novel, I knew I'd have to have it. Everything she's written I've felt a connection to. Her characters and their journeys just burrow under my skin, race through my bloodstream, and find a home in my heart. 

Sorrow is...
a love story
a grief story
a story of hope cloaked in melancholy

Sorrow may...
make you frustrated or annoyed with Joe
even when you understand why he's so quick to run away 
and so slow to embrace who he is, or could be

Sorrow will
remind you of what you may forget
about time
and action
and inaction
and loss

Sorrow should
nudge you
prod you
inspire you
invigorate you

And Sorrow will most definitely make you hope and wish that Tiffanie DeBartolo is finding her next inspiration because we all need more of her words in our heads, on our shelves, and in our hearts. I know that this novel will be absolutely perfect for so many of my former students and even some of my current ones. 

The story of October and Joe and Cal is one that I won't forget. Between October and her quirky art installations (which WOW, the time and imagination to come up with those!) and her sage wisdom on relationships and humanity, and Joe and his stubborn resistance to truly live for himself, and Cal's heart and inability to let Joe sink into nothingness, I didn't stand a chance--I was destined to love them all, and love them I did. 

Thank you, Tiffanie DeBartolo, for giving me new words, new characters to love, and a reminder to not give up before I've even started.


SYNOPSIS:

From Tiffanie DeBartolo, author of God Shaped Hole, How to Kill a Rock Star, and Grace: The Jeff Buckley Story, comes Sorrow, a poignant story about friendship and love, art and music, and how these pursuits can save us from ourselves.


Joe Harper has backpedaled throughout his life. A once-promising guitar prodigy, he's been living without direction since abandoning his musical dreams. Now into his thirties, having retreated from every opportunity he's had to level up, he has lost his family, his best friend, and his own self-respect.

 

But Joe finds an unlikely path to redemption when he starts working as a carpenter for the bohemian conceptual artist October Danko. The job returns him to his hometown, loaded with bittersweet reminders of his former life, in the shadows of his beloved redwood trees. As Joe's relationship with October develops, he yearns to take a daring step toward a bold future, but struggles to escape the craven decisions of his past.

 

Sorrow is a stunning, moving novel that explores masculinity and suspended adolescence, all the while begging the questions: Can courage be learned? And is it ever too late to follow your heart?



Monday, January 27, 2020

REVIEW: HOW TO KILL A ROCK STAR BY TIFFANIE DEBARTOLO


Written in her wonderfully honest, edgy, passionate and often hilarious voice, Tiffanie DeBartolo tells the story of Eliza Caelum, a young music journalist, and Paul Hudson, a talented songwriter and lead singer of the band Bananafish. Eliza's reverence for rock is equaled only by Paul's, and the two fall wildly in love. 

When Bananafish is signed by a big corporate label, and Paul is on his way to becoming a major rock star, Eliza must make a heartbreaking decision that leads to Paul's sudden disappearance and a surprise knock-your-socks-off ending.


Paperback, 417 pages
Published September 1st 2005 by Sourcebooks Landmark

OUR REVIEW: (ETA: this review has been sitting in our drafts folder for FIVE YEARS!!! Oops!)

I read this novel after God Shaped Hole and I'd highly recommend that you follow the same order. Why? It's a lighter read than God Shaped Hole, even with its angsty moments it's not quite as heavy as GSH--it's really quite different. In this novel rather than explore the relationship of two people working through issues of love and family and living in the world, we explore the unnecessarily complicated love affair of Eliza and Paul and their place in the world of music. 

Unnecessarily complicated? Yes, though if it hadn't been complicated I guess we wouldn't have had quite the story we did. Why do I think it was "unnecessarily complicated"? Because Eliza made decisions for people in this novel without fully thinking about what they would want or like or ...ugh. Do I think her heart was in the right place? Yes, but good lord...what a CF. What Eliza intended to do was selfless but controlling and the consequences were far and wide reaching. I know I'm making Eliza seem ...well, not great..but I did like her, even when I wanted to shake her, and I know that she was trying to do the right thing. Speaking of trying to do the right thing, Paul made decisions with that same desire to "do the right thing" in mind. He ignores his instincts and allows himself to be pressured into things he truly didn't want because he thought it would be right for his band and the impact of his decisions resulted in a craptastic results, ultimately. I know you're thinking..WHY WOULD I WANT TO READ THIS NOVEL, THEN?

Well. 

Even though Eliza and Paul are a hot mess, I liked them. They're funny and observant and flawed. 

I also loved Tiffanie DeBartolo's fears and observations on the state of music/America/pop culture, as seen through her characters, and I found myself nodding my head a lot at what Paul said (especially the younger, more idealistic version of me) while appreciating the more mellow and accepting/resigned position of Loring. I can easily see these concerns about art and artistry existing as long as humans exist. It's that push/pull of wanting to express and evoke emotion and wanting to stay true to your art versus needing to afford to live versus commercialism versus fame versus industry machines controlling the manifest destiny of EVERYTHING. oh my gosh. Let me just stop now.

Anyway.

 If Tiffanie DeBartolo ever writes anything else, I wouldn't even have to think about it, I'd snatch it up immediately. I love her prose, the observations her characters make, and the obvious care she takes in crafting her works of fiction. 

Sunday, January 10, 2016

REVIEW: GOD SHAPED HOLE BY TIFFANIE DeBARTOLO

When I was twelve, a fortune teller told me that my one true love would die young and leave me all alone.

Everyone said she was a fraud, that she was just making it up.

I'd really like to know why the hell a person would make up a thing like that.

Written with the snap, glitter and wit of The Girl's Guide to Hunting and Fishing, God-Shaped Hole is a memorable, poignant love story that will leave you weeping with laughter. It is told in the wry, vulnerable voice of Beatrice "Trixie" Jordan who replies to a personal ad, "If your intentions are pure I am seeking a friend for the end of the world."

In doing so, she meets Jacob Grace, a charming, effervescent thirty-something writer, a free spirit who is a passionate seeker of life. He possesses his own turn of phrase and ways of thinking and feeling that dissonantly harmonize with Trixie's off-center vision as they roller coaster through the joys and furies of their wrenching romance. Along the way they try to come to terms with the hurt brought about by their distant fathers who, in different ways, forsook them.

This story will prove so touching you will rush to share it with a friend or loved one or even a stranger.

Paperback, 329 pages
Published May 1st 2002 by Sourcebooks Landmark (first published January 1st 2002)
Source: Purchased
Purchase a copy: Goodreads | Amazon


Our Review: 

Shelley: I'm looking at the cursor blink and I'm trying to figure out just what the hell to say about this book; it's overwhelming to try to write about a book that you've fallen in love with. It's hard to express in any coherent way how much a book like that means and how the special people in your life should read it.

Court: Amen. I started this book after Shelley read it. And then, my father got sick. And I just lost all...I don't know...creative light in me and just couldn't get there. I mean, hello, the title is God Shaped Hole...and at the time I felt like I had a God Shaped Hole in my heart because that's what terminal illness does to you. I just couldn't do it. I can't say that I wish I had read this any differently because as I have been waking up from the fog that my grief has left me in...I feel that I finished this one at the right time for me. It is a heady novel that really hit right to the heart of me, and Tiffanie DeBartolo's writing is seriously so freaking awesome you guys. I'm sure I should say that more...eloquently...but it is beautiful and really sneaks up on your senses. 

Shel: Here's the thing--I'm not going to talk about technical stuff or try to recap plot or ramble in any sort of meaningful way about all of the components that work--I can't do that yet. I need to reread it but it's not one of those books that I can jump right back in to...I need time to think about it and love it. I promise I'll add an addendum when I tackle it again this summer...and it hopefully it will delve more into those things. Court: I hope that I can one day try to read it again. It was such a special book that I bet it is one of those that I will come out completely reformed and reshaped again, and again. Trixie and Jacob are wild and zany in their own way, and each of their life journey holds grief in such different ways...but their story is one of helping and healing, and random and all of the things that is unique and lovely. 

Shel: Maybe this book just happened to me at the right time-- though I doubt it, I think it's just that good. I needed to read a book that tapped into some of the same things I was feeling; a book that could capture a sense of joy and melancholy and foreboding and love and pure sadness. I needed a book to commiserate with the myriad of tiny, but sharp, emotions that have been zinging around my head for weeks--and this did that. Court: It really did tap into the emotions of dealing with our every day life, and understanding our parents...or in these two's case not understanding them, but as a twenty something couple just trying to figure out where we will go in life together...I can relate. And the other thing...the utter anxiety of hoping your loved ones remain safe every single day is there too. I get it. I feel it. I thank this novel for helping me understand it better. 

Shel: I wanted to live in between the words of this novel; that's how much I felt it. It creeped into my bones and into my soul and not many books do that for me these days. A not-so-well kept secret about me is that I'm cynical and sarcastic and I don't let many things under my skin...I don't let many things wedge themselves into my heart and maybe in a few months I'll think I was overstating this, but for now? this novel is in my heart. Court: I am so glad, Shel! I like finding (or in this case someone else, I think Jaime, recommending) a book that will effect her this way. My greatest joy in life is finding something that will make her heart squeeze, and maybe, just maybe make her eyes leak. It doesn't happen often, so it is a high compliment if it does. 

Shel: I hope you'll read it (I'm betting Court will cry)--but you should only read it if you're one of those special people--the ones who like to feel a little emo with me. Court: Damn it, I hope y'all don't ever bet against her if she says I will cry...because that is the likeliest thing ever to come out of her mouth. I did. And I still think about this book every day. It was beautiful, and worth every minute spent in the world of beautiful characters and even more beautiful writing. 

© Must Read Books or Die. Made with love by The Dutch Lady Designs.